Showing posts with label Pharisees. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pharisees. Show all posts

Saturday, September 10, 2016

Some Rich Dude and Lazarus

This is the study page for the Thursday Night Bible Study Group meeting September 15 to study Luke 16:14-31.  The chances are good we won't get through the whole thing, but it might be possible to do all of it.

This is the completion of Jesus' teachings on wealth from this chapter.  It seems to move the issue to the heart or attitude of people, and for some reason include divorce.  It concludes with the parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus.  The elements of this part of the chapter are hard to follow and the details can be distracting from seeing a main point (sort of like the last one).

Read through the entire chapter at least once to get a sense the overall context.  As you begin to focus on the statements of Jesus in verses 14 through 18, seek the connecting thread.  Break down the parable based on the preceding statements of Jesus and His audience.  As we noticed last week it's good to read the parable in a few translations.  This one may have as many differences as the previous one, but it's still a great exercise.  The NIV with NASB, NLT with ESV, and NRSV with NKJV are good pairings (any of the first suggestions with any of the second will work as well).  Make notes and questions for yourself as you go.  Then see what commentaries have to say.

After you done your own work, go back through with the questions below:
  • Once again, the Pharisees are close enough to hear Jesus speaking to His disciples.  So, how likely is it that at least some Pharisees made up the number of Jesus' disciples (not the 12, but followers)?
  • These Pharisees scoff at Jesus.  So, following closely enough to hear Him speak to His disciples, they don't necessarily buy in or completely buy in to His views of righteousness.  Why do you think that might be?  How close do you think we need to be to Jesus' views to be considered disciples?
  • The Pharisees "justify" themselves, a term which nearly every translation uses, but what do you think this means?  Look at the Greek word on the Blue Letter Bible here.  If you want more information, follow the link to the root word (G1342).  How does this help you understand what the Pharisees were doing?  How does this help you see this activity in yourself?
  • The final statement of verse 15 is interesting in that it sounds very much like a blanket statement about everything lifted up among people being detested by God.  Why do you think Jesus put it that way?  What point do you think He's trying to make?
  • Jesus uses the word "abomination" or "detestable thing" which is actually a technical theological term in Judaism.  Look at the Greek word on Blue Letter Bible here.  Pay special attention to its usage in other places.  How do you think the Pharisees heard Jesus' statement?  What do you think they thought when He said that?
  • In verse 16, we have a really strange statement by Jesus.  This is one verse that really needs several versions, not just one to get a good sense of.  Here again, the Blue Letter Bible will provide an excellent set of parallels.  Pay special attention to the KJV, NIV, NASB, and ESV translations of it.  What do you think Jesus means about John being a "boundary" of some sort?  What do you think Jesus means by people entering the Kingdom of God by force?  What do you think was preached before John if it wasn't the "Kingdom of God"?
  • Verse 17 is a well-known statement from Matthew (17:18) as well.  How do you think this statement relates to the two previous verses?
  • Verse 18 has parallels in Matthew (5:31-32, 19:9) and Mark (10:11,12).  How do you think this teaching on divorce relates to wealth, the law, and what God finds detestable?  Why do you think Luke put it here?
  • The parable of the "Rich Man & Lazarus" begins with the setting of the two characters in verses 19 through 21.  What are your first impressions?  Why do you think Jesus made them so incredibly opposite?
  • The rich guy ends up in hell, and Lazarus in "heaven".  Why?  What clues do you have for why one went one place and the other to the other?
  • The description of the "after-life" is pretty spooky, one side can see the other but neither can get to the other.  What do you think of that?
  • Hell (Hades) is "torment" in verse 23, or "agony" due to "flame" in verse 24.  What do you think of this description, in agonizing torment by fire yet able to see the other side where they aren't?
  • Notice Lazarus never speaks in this parable.  Why do you think might be important to Jesus' point?
  • Abraham has several comments on the rich man's situation (verses 25, 26, and 29), they get progressively more depressing (from irreconcilable agony to it being his own fault).  What do you think of this assessment of the description of this afterlife?
  • The rich man constantly wants Lazarus to do this or that, come here, go there.  What does this tell you about the rich man's understanding of himself and Lazarus?  How different do you think this is from when they were both alive?
  • Obviously Abraham's final statement relates to Jesus' resurrection and people's persistent unbelief.  Why do you think Jesus would include that to people following Him closely?  What does that tell you about people, even those who follow Him closely?
That should be plenty to keep us busy, probably for a few weeks.  Consider where you see God seeing you in these passages.  It's easy to see others, but the Holy Spirit desires to awaken you to growth in your relationship with Him, just as Jesus was prodding the Pharisees in much the same way, to be authentic with their belief and pursuit of a relationship with God.

Friday, July 29, 2016

Dealing With Pharisees Part I: Testing The Teacher

This is the Bible study page for the Thursday Night Bible Study Group meeting August 4 to study Luke 13:31-14:6.  I believe that I told everyone last Thursday that the "Dinner Party" started in verse 7, but I was wrong.  Chapter 14 verses 1 through 24 are the same "dinner party" in Luke.  So, we'll begin it this week and finish it next.

It will be helpful to read the context of this dinner party.  It forms one event in Luke, but could possibly have been a composite of several dinners with any number of hosts.  Luke has this as one event, which is also a possibility.  Either way, Jesus is not all that comfortable a guest to have in the house of this particular host.  He eventually insults the host and the other guests, thoroughly.

Read through the passage (this part, and the rest through 24 for context) several times.  Try and get a sense of the setting.  Journey, Pharisees coming to Jesus to warn Him about Herod, and then a chief of theirs invites Him to dinner.  How nice.  Everyone seems to be getting along.  Make notes from the perspective of yourself standing among the crowd witnessing this.  Including looking in on the dinner party as they recline with some diseased person standing there with them (how does that look in your mind?).  Make notes on what you see, what you hear, who is doing what, and why.

After you gone through your own observation journey, perhaps read it through in different translations, then maybe read a commentary or two.  See if that helps to define the scene better for you.  Adjust your notes and questions accordingly.

Then go back through with the questions below:
  • Luke is clear to point out the immediacy of the next event.  Why do you think Luke would tie the Pharisees warning so closely with the previous statements?
  • They warn that Herod wants to kill Jesus.  How likely, based on the crucifixion account later, do you think it is that they are right?
  • Jesus responds that He must go to Jerusalem, because no prophet can die outside of the city.  While that's not strictly true, what do you think Jesus is getting at?
  • Jesus has to cast out demons and perform cures on His way, but look at the timing.  To what do you think Jesus may be referring in His "third day" reference?
  • Jesus then prophesies over Jerusalem in the form of a lament.  How do you feel about Jesus' words?  What emotions do they evoke for you?
  • Jesus has wanted to gather the city like chicks under the wings of a mother hen.  As people hear this, what do you think they think about His words?  What do you think this sounds like? See if you can find a reference to this imagery in the Hebrew Scriptures (Hen gathering her chicks).
  • What do you think Jesus' last comment refers to, His Triumphal Entry or His eventual appearing later? 
  • Jesus then enters the house of one of the leaders of the Pharisees.  How possible do you think it is that the preceding account was some sort of test?  What do you think the connection is?
  • The "Guests" are watching Jesus very closely with a diseased person standing there.  He's obviously a plant (a human planted intentionally at the scene, not a shrub).  Jesus has already healed on the Sabbath several times already in Luke, so why would they be watching for what shouldn't really surprise them?  Have they not heard Jesus defend healing on the Sabbath before?  Don't these guys talk to each other?
  • The man has a disease referred to in the KJV as "dropsy" and many other translations have picked this term as well.  Other modern versions call it "swelling".  Look up the word here in the Blue Letter Bible site.  What do you think it means, and what problems do you see in figuring that out?
  • Jesus asks the guests (lawyers and Pharisees) about the legality before He heals.  Why do you think He would do that?
  • They remains silent when asked about the legality.  Considering that Pharisees and lawyers don't always agree on things, why do you think they might have remained silent?
  • Jesus heals the man and send him away.  Then starts the discussion.  What does it tell you about Jesus that He heals and sends him away first, then discusses it?
  • Jesus then asks, who doesn't pull a son or a cow (really? cow?) out of a well on the Sabbath.  Again no one says a thing.  What is interesting to you about His question?  Consider His previous questions (13:15-16 for example), what is different here?
  • They could not give an answer.  The NIV says they had nothing to say, but other translations state they were not able, and the Greek reads that way.  What do you think it means that they could not answer, why not?
That should keep us busy for some time.  Remember to be looking for the AHA moments as you read.  Let this stuff sink into your heart and remember it's for you in your walk with Jesus.  Let His Spirit interpret for you what He wants to reveal about you.  These are growth opportunities, let's grab them!

Saturday, May 14, 2016

This Generation Needs Help

This is the Bible study page for the Thursday Night Bible Study Group meeting May 19 to study Luke 11:29-54 (the end of the chapter).  This is a collection of passages bristling with bristling, insults, condemnation, flagrant offense, and an uncomfortable meal.  Just bristling!  Say the word out loud, you know it's fun.

Reading through these passages, it might be easier to break them up into the smallest cohesive pieces.  Then you perhaps group the pieces.  It's up to you where you think the breaks should be, but breaking them up might make them easier to understand.  If you look at the passages in various translations, you'll see that translators don't even know where to break them up.  The two biggest elements are the condemnation of the ones looking for a sign and the dinner with the Pharisee.  But beyond that, you may find it easier to break into smaller pieces.  It's up to you, you may not find that easier at all.  If not, don't do it.

Once you have the passage grouped in a way that makes sense, focus on the relationships between each element (even if it's only two).  Then look at the elements within each, like the woes on Pharisees versus lawyers.  How do those relate?  And so on, it's like assembling a quilt sort of.  Stepping back gives you the sense of how the whole works together.  Zooming in helps get a sense of how Jesus addresses what problems He sees.  On that note, what problems does He see?  What problems seem to draw most of His attention?

Jot down questions and insights you gain from your own study.  Then look at commentaries or notes, or whatever you have at hand.  Revise your notes and questions.  Bring those to the group, Thursday.  After you have all that, then go back through with the questions below:
  • Verse 29 seems to address those mentioned in verse 16 who were demanding a sign.  Jesus says it's wicked to want a sign.  What do you think Jesus and the people mean by "sign"? Sign of or for what?
  • In Matthew 12:38-42, we have a parallel to verse 29 through 32, but there Matthew explains how Jonah is a sign to the Ninevites.  So, how do you think Luke understands Jonah as a "sign" to the people of Nineveh?  Is it the time in the fish, or his preaching, or what?  
  • The "Queen of the South" came to hear Solomon, and Jonah went to Nineveh.  She desired to hear Solomon's wisdom and the Ninevites needed to hear from God.  How are these two things related to each other?  I think it relates to what the people around Jesus are not doing.  If that is true, what do you think they are not doing?  Do we do these things or are we not doing them either?
  • Starting at verse 33, I think we have another separate element that, for Luke, is related to what precedes it.  From 33 to 36, Jesus is referring to "light", but what do you think that "light" is a metaphor for here?  In other places it refers to other things, but what does Jesus use it for here?
  • Jesus says that light is meant to be displayed.  How do you think the people around Jesus have been hiding theirs?
  • Jesus says that the eye enlightens the body.  How do you think the people around Jesus have been "darkening" their vision?
  • From the two elements, about signs and about light, what is Jesus trying to get across to the people around Him?  What do you think is the unifying truth behind both?
  • Next, a Pharisee invites Jesus to a meal.  As I've told you in the past, this is always dangerous.  Right away, the Pharisee is surprised Jesus doesn't wash.  The word used is "baptize".  What does that tell you about "baptism"?  So why do you think the King James would not, nor does any other translation, use the word "baptize" for this?
  • The Pharisee is "astonished" or "surprised" that Jesus doesn't wash.  There's nothing inherently negative in this word, so what do you think might have been going on in the Pharisee's mind?
  • Jesus launches into a condemnation of the Pharisees.  The first condemnation is appearing clean but not being clean on the outside.  But what do you think Jesus means when He says, "But give that which is within as charity, and then all things are clean for you."?  How are all things "clean"?  In what way?
  • Jesus then goes into tithing every little thing, but not behaving in just and loving ways.  How do you think this is like or unlike us today?
  • The Pharisees have come to love the "trappings" of their station.  What do you think is the alternative?  Luke really doesn't say, so what do you think Luke and his hearers have in mind?
  • What do you think is the problem depicted in "hidden tombs"?  Why do you think it is a problem to walk over a grave?
  • Now a lawyer stands up...again.  And this genius claims that Jesus is also insulting them, as if by accident.  Why do you think the lawyer would exclude his group from the Pharisees?  
  • He clearly seems to see some of Jesus' criticisms as applying to lawyers also.  What or which ones of Jesus' woes do you think the lawyer thought applied to him and the other lawyers?
  • Jesus takes up the challenge to be more direct toward the lawyers, and so begins His woes on them.  What do you think are these burdens these lawyers are laying on the people they do not lift themselves?  Do you think the lawyers would agree with Jesus assessment of them that they don't lift them either?
  • How do you think building the tomb for a prophet makes a person in agreement with those who killed him?
  • Literally, the wording of verse 49 says, "Through this also the wisdom of God said..."  The NIV reads "God in His wisdom", the NASB has "the wisdom of God", and the ESV has "the Wisdom of God".  So, which do you think makes more sense here?  Who do you think Jesus thinks said this?
  • Why would the blood of Abel be charged to the generation to whom Jesus spoke?
  • Why would the blood of Zechariah (2 Chronicles 24:20-22) be charged to them?
  • Lawyers were supposed to be making the law clear to people.  So in what way do you think they kept the "key" to it from people?
  • Understandably, the lawyers and Pharisees began to plot against Jesus, but what do you think of their "plan"?  Considering how much fun everyone had at the meal, does this sound like a great idea to you?  Why do you think they wanted this approach?
This should be plenty to keep us busy.  See you all Thursday!

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

When Slap-Fights Go Horribly Wrong

This is the study page for the Thursday Night Group meeting on April 4, to study Acts 23.  We will begin with Paul's defense before the Sanhedrin, and move to his eventual removal to the Judean coast.

Read through Chapter 23 several times.  It will be hard not to continue on to the succeeding chapters, and continuing may be a good thing to do.  Chapter 24 is fairly short and the story moves quickly to its conclusion from here.  We have two governors, a king and a boat trip left after this chapter.

As you read through the chapter, slow down, re-read difficult sentences, try and imagine yourself in the event. Ask yourself questions about what it would have been like to have been there, what it looked like, what are the expressions on faces, what do their voices sound like.  Once you can put together some idea of a "setting" using your imagination, ask yourself the "why" questions.  This is narrative, and fast-moving narrative.  You have to think and imagine in order to slow it down to really observe.  This is inspired of God, so it's worth the effort; there's a goal in mind here, find it.

Once you've sifted through the chapter a few times, and come up with some questions, read it through again, and consider these.  They're not replacements, or the "right questions", they're ones from my different perspective.  We need your perspective in order to get a more full view of these events; we can't really understand the game with just the view from one "knot-hole".
  • Paul's opening statement seems to offend the high priest, why?
  • To whom does Paul address his "rebuke" when he is struck?  What tells us he knew who the man was?
  • When Paul is told who the man was to ordered he be struck, how does he respond, with what sort of attitude?
  • Paul then changes tactics dramatically.  Why?  What about how he started won't work with this group?
  • What does his declaration about the resurrection do to the assembly?
  • If you're the "commander", what has happened to your dilemma?  Now what do you do?
  • Who appears to Paul to encourage him?  What is remarkable about that?
  • What is really "stupid" about the oath the Jews take concerning Paul?  What is really important if they are going to live out this oath?
  • What do the "oath-takers" do to try to get to Paul?
  • Why would the council, divided the night before, play along with the conspiracy?
  • Who hears of the plot?  Where must he have been?  Why might he have been there?
  • What does that tell you of Paul's family?  This is really the first we hear of any of them, so where are some or many of them?  How is Paul viewed by his family?
  • To whom does Paul send his nephew?  Why not go himself or with his nephew?
  • How does the commander respond when the boy is brought to him?  Why this way?
  • What does the commander do when he hears what the boy has to say?
  • What does he tell the Sanhedrin?  When does he tell them?  Where is Paul when the Sanhedrin hears from the commander?
  • What does that mean for the oath-takers?  I suppose that's "more than forty" fewer problems for Paul?
  • What does the commander tell the governor about Paul?  What does he leave out or change about his involvement?
So we leave Paul, again waiting on another "trial" and will have to wait until next week to continue the story.  It may be possible to get chapters 24 and 25 done at once since 24 and 25 are so short.  Chapters 26, 27 and 28 will not be so easy.  So, possibly 4 weeks after this.

Tuesday, September 25, 2012

Staying Alive In Church

This is the page for the small group meeting Thursday, September 27.  This week we will be in Acts 5 (or at least start it).  It's a long chapter and a lot happens, so we'll get through as much as we can in the time we have.

As you read through the chapter, notice that the first eleven verses really are a continuation of the last 5 of chapter 4.  The rest of the chapter is made up of the near extinction of very happy apostles.  Read through the chapter a few times and look for the odd things people do, or don't do (the religious leaders, the apostles, and what are the people doing?).  Write down questions that come up and bring them to the group Thursday.

After reading through several times, consider these questions as you read through a final time:
  • When did Ananias claim all the money was at Peter's feet?
  • What would Ananias and Sapphira gain by lying? What probably motivated them?
  • Why would they think they could "pull it off"?
  • Why do you think Sapphira didn't hear about her husband's death at some point?
  • When verses 13 and 14 are taken together, how do people join the group?
  • What is drawing people from the outlying areas into Jerusalem?
  • What does it take to be healed by Peter?
  • Who do the religious leaders lock up?
  • Which segment of the religious leaders does this?
  • Who leads the apostles out, and why tell them to go back to the temple?
  • If the captain and his officers fear being stoned by the people, why would the religious leaders not fear the same thing?
  • Read the article on the sect of the Pharisees at this link (or at least the part on their beliefs - section II).  Why would this group give any support to the believers against the Sadducees?
  • What about Gamaliel's point makes some sense?  What doesn't?
  • Look up Theudas at this link.  Which explanation sounds better to you?
  • Look up Judas of Galilee at this link.  Which of these two do you think makes better support for Gamaliel's point?
  • Consider the reason for the apostles (remember Acts 1:21-22), what might have happened to the church had the assembly carried out their initial intent?
  • So, instead of killing them, what does the assembly do?
  • How effective a threat/punishment is it?
  • What do the apostles do after the flogging?
  • How does the church respond to these events?
That should do for the next few days.  I am looking forward to studying this passage with you.  Remember each other before our Master.  Blessings upon you until we see each other Thursday!